County Council Election May 1958
Aithsting
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Frederick B. Tait | Unopposed |
Bressay
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Prophet Smith | Unopposed |
Burra and Quarff
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Robert Strachan | Unopposed |
Cunningsburgh
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Joan McLeod | Unopposed |
Delting North
| Candidate | Votes | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Sir Basil Neven-Spence | 94 | Elected |
| Thomas A. Hughson | 36 | Not elected |
Delting South
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
 Edward Percival Adie | Unopposed |
Dunrossness North
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Tom Henderson | Unopposed |
Dunrossness South
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| James J. Gordon | Unopposed |
Fetlar
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
 Charles Brown | Unopposed |
Gulberwick
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| John W. Irvine | Unopposed |
Nesting And Lunnasting
| Candidate | Votes | Result |
|---|---|---|
| William R. T. Hamilton | 112 | Elected |
| John R. Smith | 111 | Not elected |
Northmavine North
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Hamish A. S. Brydone | Unopposed |
Northmavine South
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Robert Balfour | Unopposed |
Sandness
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Robert J. H. Ganson | Unopposed |
Sandsting
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
 Alexander I. Tulloch | Unopposed |
Sandwick
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Robert H. W. Bruce | Unopposed |
Tingwall
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| George K. Spence | Unopposed |
Unst North
| Candidate | Votes | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Laurence D. Edmondston | 149 | Elected |
| Lindsay Robertson | 61 | Not elected |
Unst South
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| James L. Matches | Unopposed |
Walls
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
| Peter Henry | Unopposed |
Whalsay And Skerries
| Candidate | Votes | Result |
|---|---|---|
 Magnus Shearer | 184 | Elected |
| John M. Gray | 174 | Not elected |
Whiteness And Weisdale
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
 Anthony Anderson | Unopposed |
Yell North
| Candidate | Result |
|---|---|
 Amanda Youngman | Unopposed |
Yell South
| Candidate | Votes | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Charles G. Spence | 191 | Elected |
 John R. Tulloch | 179 | Not elected |