Tingwall
| Year | Type | Winner | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1890 | general | Arthur J. Hay | 102 |
| 1892 | general | Arthur J. Hay | 80 |
| 1895 | general | Arthur J. Hay | 95 |
| 1897 | by-election | Alexander C. Hay | Unanimously elected |
| 1898 | general | Alexander C. Hay | Unopposed |
| 1901 | general | William Rae Duncan | 133 |
| 1904 | general | William Duncan | Unopposed |
| 1907 | general | William Rae Duncan | Unopposed |
| 1909 | by-election | Lewis James Garriock | Unanimously appointed |
| 1910 | general | Lewis James Garriock | Unopposed |
| 1913 | general | Robert Inkster | Unopposed |
| 1919 | by-election | James Peter Mouat | Unanimously elected |
| 1919 | general | James Peter Mouat | Unopposed |
| 1922 | general | James Peter Mouat | Unopposed |
| 1925 | general | James P. Mouat | Unopposed |
| 1928 | general | James Peter Mouat | Unopposed |
| 1929 | general | James Peter Mouat | Unopposed |
| 1932 | general | James Peter Mouat | Unopposed |
| 1935 | general | Selina Garriock | 228 |
| 1938 | general | Westwood Norman Hay | Unopposed |
| 1945 | general | George Ross | 198 |
| 1949 | general | George Ross | Unopposed |
| 1950 | by-election | George K. Spence | 233 |
| 1952 | general | George K. Spence | Unopposed |
| 1955 | general | George K. Spence | Unopposed |
| 1958 | general | George K. Spence | Unopposed |
| 1961 | general | George K. Spence | Unopposed |
| 1964 | general | Andrew B. Irvine | 174 |
| 1967 | general | see the 1967 Tingwall by-election.'' | |
| 1967 | by-election | Andrew B. Irvine | Unanimously elected |
| 1970 | general | Andrew B. Irvine | Unopposed |
| 1973 | general | Andrew B. Irvine | 327 |